The Downside to Debt Consolidation Loans

Posted on September 24, 2007 by Eric 
Filed Under Credit Cards, Debt

I would like one loan for everything please!When I started my first job after college, I didn’t own much. I had my car, some hand-me-down furniture, some clothes, a TV and VCR, a computer, some books, and a variety of other small things. I didn’t have much in the way of assets, and the furniture I had was really starting to show it’s age.

I managed to get a good job and it payed well. Considering I had so little when I moved, and I thought I was doing well, I decided to “move on up”. I upgraded my TV from a 13″ to a 27″. I bought new furniture, including new couches, coffee table, entertainment center, and end tables. I bought some movies, new books, and a smattering of other things. Before I knew it, I had $12,000 in credit card bills. By some people’s standards, that might not seem like a lot. For me at the time, it was huge. My father had always told me to avoid debt, and never carry a balance on your credit card. He’s never had to pay a finance charge on his credit card before. I hadn’t either up until this point.

I knew I had to find a way to pay the debt down. So I took out a debt consolidation loan against my car. Everything worked out fine, and I managed to get out of debt at that point fairly painlessly. I didn’t learn the lesson completely (I’ve had debt since this incident), but in my case the debt consolidation loan actually worked out pretty well, and saved me some money in the end.

Now, I’ve got a friend who has never handled his money well. He’s made some bad decisions in his life when it comes to finances. He’s actually a very, very smart guy, but he just doesn’t always think when it comes to spending money. I guess I’ve been there too, so I don’t judge him, but he did make a decision that confused me recently.

Things had been going well for him for a bit, and he just got a debt consolidation loan. This loan lowers his overall payment requirements each month, has a lower interest rate, and helps him get all his debt into one place. It looked like a pretty good plan to help him get out of debt.

But then, shortly after he had everything setup, he went out and made some purchases on his newly paid-off credit cards. After going through all the trouble to consolidate his loans he started filling up his credit cards again and created even more debt. He purchased some things that he wanted, but couldn’t afford until he had more room on his credit cards. The things he bought were far from necessities.

Now he has to worry about paying off both the loan and the new credit card balances. It seems that he’ll be in debt for a while longer. He understands what he’s done, and that it’s not the best financial move, but it doesn’t seem to change his behavior. Instead of working to pay down that loan, he just compounded it by adding even more debt.

Normally I wouldn’t advocate cutting up your credit cards. We use our credit cards extensively, but we ensure that each month we don’t carry a balance so we avoid paying finance charges. If you use your credit cards responsibly they can be a very convenient and useful tool. If you have rewards, you can even get some cash back or some other type of reward for using them. In this case, I think my friend is too tempted by available credit and might be better off just cutting up his cards.

If you get a debt consolidation loan, make sure you keep these things in mind :

Debt consolidation loans can work for you, but only if you work within some basic guidelines and exercise your self-control when it comes to your credit cards. According to Bankrate.com, 70% of people who get debt consolidation loans have the same, or higher, debt loads 2 years after they get the loans. If you think a debt consolidation loan would work for you, do some research before you commit to anything. Get some help from a financial advisor if you can. Don’t wind up in the 70% that don’t reduce their debt at all.

Image Source: SqueakyMarmot

Related Posts

Comments

9 Responses to “The Downside to Debt Consolidation Loans”

  1. Roundup for week of 23 September 2007: Plumbing fixtures edition at Mighty Bargain Hunter on September 30th, 2007 10:48 pm

    [...] A Penny Closer reveals a downside to debt consolidation loans. [...]

  2. How to Solve Money Worries Blog Carnival on October 6th, 2007 9:57 am

    [...] presents The Downside to Debt Consolidation Loans posted at A Penny [...]

  3. Bankruptcy Regina(new comment) on December 30th, 2008 2:24 pm

    Great article and tips! This is very useful information for my clients. I will definitely be referring them to your blog.

  4. Current account(new comment) on January 23rd, 2009 5:00 am

    there have always been three ways of clearing debt:

    1. repay it
    2. inflate it away, or let the Government do it for you
    3. default

    I once read as book on international debt which stated “1″ was by far the most common. White Russains and various African and American countries/states apparently used to be masters at this. Too much debt, time for a revolution.

    Inflation used to be great but no more.

    Default is now much easier with IVAs readily available on every high street and bankruptcy much less painful. With an IVA you can still stay in business and I know qualified accountants and solicitors who have gone this route and kept their practices running!! But it does not help your credit history.

    But it you decide to repay then you only have two choices – earn more or spend less. But it can make a lot of differcne how you apply these policies and you may find it useful to visit this web site – it is a US site but I found it quite useful.

  5. The Debt Wiz(new comment) on February 28th, 2009 3:51 pm

    Yes, debt consolidation can help you if you are willing and have the discipline to control your spending habits. I’ve seen way too many people get even further in debt, mainly because they don’t change their habits. I believe anyone who gets a debt consolidation loan should also get some type of credit counseling at the same time to prevent them from racking up more debt.

  6. AFRICA(new comment) on March 10th, 2009 8:19 am

    Am after a loan but am very sceptical these days, there are a lot of sharks out there, can you point me to an article that explains all the different types of loans please? Thank you :D

  7. Neil(new comment) on May 2nd, 2009 5:17 pm

    Hi

    Unfortunately this is such a common story with debt consolidation – your friend should really have terminated his credit cards when he got the consolidation loan.

    Neil

  8. Mark Aucamp(new comment) on May 23rd, 2009 6:29 am

    Think carefully before doing a debt consolidation. You will be adding an unsecured debt to a secured debt and you could lose your home if you then do not pay your mortgage. You should beaware that you will ultimately increase the amount you borrow by paying it back over a longer period. Think Carefully before consolidating a debt. If it is the right course of action then go ahead as it will provide you with cheaper repayments.

  9. Credit Card Tip(new comment) on July 6th, 2010 2:00 am

    The CitiBusiness PremierPass Card provides for several benefits. First, you will enjoy 12 months of an introductory 0% rate on balance transfers. You will need to submit for these transfers within the first 12 months of having the credit line. You will also enjoy a low APR of 13.99% that is variable and 22.99% APR on cash advances. There is an annual fee on this credit card at $75 but it will be waived for your first year with the company. This allows the card to be affordable, yet with the negative of an annual fee

U COMMENT
I FOLLOW

Leave a Reply